Natalya Pulaski
April 17, 2013
EN101.17
Event Analysis 6
William
Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night and the
event entitled “Aristotle, Aquinas & Machiavelli walk into a Board Room…” examine
the role of wisdom and how it can have an effect on relationships. Shakespeare explores the role of romantic
love. Although in most instances,
romantic love appears to play a positive role in relationships, Shakespeare
illustrates how romantic love can turn the wrong way when people do not use
their wisdom correctly. The play revolves
around the love triangle of Viola, Olivia and Orsino who all try to win each
other over with their love, which ultimately causes bad choices to be made
because of secretive love and deception.
The event I attended discussed the role of prudential wisdom in the
business world and how certain business choices people make can reduce our
prudential wisdom.
Shakespeare’s use
of reversal of roles causes romantic relationships to loose a sense of wisdom. Viola
mistakenly falls in love with Duke after trying to protect her own identity
from Illyria and after admiring Olivia’s inspiring character. Viola’s choice to disguise herself as a
eunuch, Cesario, demonstrates her bravery and independence. However, her decision to cover up her real
identity causes her to loose a sense of her initial purpose of making herself
disguised. Unintentionally, she creates
a love triangle between herself, Orsino and Olivia. Olivia falls for Cesario’s youthful personality
and good looks while Orsino is still passionately in love with Olivia. Olivia also loses a sense of her initial
promises to not fall for any men, however she is very easily swayed by
Cesario’s good looks.
Together, Orsino
and Olivia become caught up in their own self-interest of wanting to be in
love. Orsino and Duke solely want to be
in love for the sake of being in love rather than actually appreciating love
for itself and the other person in the relationship. In Act 1 scene 1, when Orsino’s character is
first introduced, Shakespeare hints at Orsino’s selfishness and high self
esteem. In the first lines of the play Orsino
reflects on love. He says that love is
like an “appetite”(1). He explains that,
“If music be the food of love, play on” but then quickly demands only a few
lines later, “Enough, no more”(1). Here,
Orsino is easily persuaded by what others have told him about love. He explains that if music is what is making
people fall in love than keep on playing, yet he complains that the music is
too much and demands it to stop. He then
describes love as “quick and fresh”(1).
Orsino’s own lack of wisdom makes him easily persuaded to change his
mind and be influenced by others. He
sees love on a very superficial level like it is like eating. He does not seem to appreciate the purpose of
being in love.
Similarly,
Shakespeare illustrates a lack of wisdom in the relationship between Sir Andrew
and Sir Toby Belch. Sir Toby Belch
deceives Sir Andrew by taking advantage of his money and his easily swayed
character. Sir Toby Belch uses his comical
wisdom as a way to highlight Sir Andrew’s apparent stupidity. Sir Toby Belch uses Sir Andrew’s stupidity as
a way to use him solely for the purpose of his wealth. He convinces Sir Andrew that Olivia is in love
with him, even though she is in love with Cesario. Here, Shakespeare seems to be contributing a
certain comical aspect to the situation, however, Sir Toby Belch is making an
immoral choice to manipulate Sir Andrew.
Shakespeare’s Twelfth Night relates to the event I
attended in the sense of making the right choices in life. The talk discussed the role of prudential
wisdom in business and as a guiding principle in people’s lives. A professor from Boston College discussed on
the topic of prudential wisdom and what it meant, for Aristotle, Aquinas &
Machiavelli and in today’s modern time, to have prudential wisdom. He described prudential wisdom as knowing
what is in fact good. He explained that
certain choices can restrict our morality, which can further reduce our
prudential wisdom.
Twelfth Night and
the event I attended have taught me how decisions can have consequences. I have also learned that wisdom is one of the
most important things that guides decisions.
Romantic relationships can be more complicated than just wanting
love. True relationships and good choices
involve morality and wisdom.
No comments:
Post a Comment